When a Massachusetts Home Sale Falls Through
Inspection, financing, appraisal, and a buyer or seller who will not perform. How the offer and the purchase and sale decide the deposit, and how to relist or start the next search without guessing at a failure rate.
Updated November 17, 2026. A deal that does not close is a contract problem and a calendar problem. The deposit, the deadlines, and the next listing all depend on what the offer and the purchase and sale actually say. Massachusetts does not publish one statewide “failure rate,” and there is no single required deposit. Anyone who quotes you one is guessing.
This is the sequence I walk through with buyers and sellers in Reading, North Reading, Wakefield, and Lynnfield when a transaction starts to come apart. Your attorney, not this page, decides whether a deadline was met.
Where deals actually break
- Inspection. The buyer can usually cancel or renegotiate only inside the inspection language in the offer. After that window, “we changed our mind about the furnace” is not a contingency.
- Financing. A pre-approval is not a commitment. The financing contingency, if you still have one, has a date. Missing the date can waive the protection. A job change, new debt, or an appraisal the lender will not use are common reasons a commitment never arrives.
- Appraisal. If the appraisal is below the price, the lender bases the loan on the appraised value. The buyer can bring the difference in cash, the seller can reduce the price, or the contract ends if neither happens and a contingency still allows it. There is no automatic rule that the seller must drop to the appraisal.
- Title, association documents, or the walk-through. A lien, an unpaid condo special assessment, or a house that is not in the condition the purchase and sale requires can stop a closing. Those are document problems. They get solved, renegotiated, or they end the deal.
- Someone simply will not perform. A buyer who waived protections and then refuses to close, or a seller who will not sign, is a default question for the attorneys. The remedy is in the purchase and sale, which may include keeping the deposit, returning it, or asking a court for specific performance. I do not promise which one you will get.
Offer to purchase versus purchase and sale
Massachusetts usually uses two contracts. The offer to purchase sets the price, the closing date, and the contingencies. The purchase and sale, negotiated by the attorneys afterward, is the long form: deposit, default, possession, and what happens to personal property. If the deal dies before the purchase and sale is signed, the offer controls. After both sides sign the purchase and sale, that document controls. Read the deadline before you assume you can still walk away. The buyer guide and the seller guide show where those documents sit in the timeline.
What happens to the deposit
The deposit is the amount written in the offer, and then the amount written in the purchase and sale. Some offers use a small first check and a larger check at the purchase and sale. Some do not. Nothing on this page should be read as “everyone puts down 5%” or any other figure. If you cancel under a contingency, on time and in the way the contract requires, the deposit is supposed to come back. If you cancel with no contingency left, the seller may be entitled to keep it. If the two sides disagree, the broker or attorney holding the money generally will not release it until both sides sign or a court or other process orders it. A dispute is a reason to call the attorney the same day, not a reason to relist and hope the check clears.
If you are the seller
Ask three questions the day you learn the buyer is out. Did they cancel inside a contingency? Where is the deposit, and who has to sign to release it? What will a new buyer see when the listing comes back, including the days it was under agreement? Then decide whether the price and the photos are still right. A house that returns to the market is not automatically worth less, and it is not automatically worth the same. Get a fresh valuation if the comps have moved. The town seller pages are the longer version of getting back on the market: Reading, North Reading, Wakefield, and Lynnfield.
Tell the next buyer the truth about why the first deal ended if the listing history makes the question obvious. Inspection items you already know about should be disclosed. Hiding them to “reset the listing” creates the second failed deal.
If you are the buyer
If you are still inside a contingency and you do not want the house, exercise it in writing before the deadline. If you still want the house and the problem is price or a repair, negotiate that in writing too. Do not stop returning calls and assume the contract expires. If the seller is the one who will not close, your attorney is the person who tells you whether you can recover the deposit and whether specific performance is realistic. Keep your pre-approval alive so you can write the next offer. A dead loan file is a slower restart than a cancelled purchase.
How to make the next contract less fragile
- Put real dates on inspection, financing, and purchase and sale, and put them on a calendar.
- Do not waive a contingency you cannot afford to waive. A waived inspection does not make the house sound. It makes the deposit harder to get back.
- Match the closing date to the lender’s lock. The rate lock guide is about that calendar.
- Use a Massachusetts attorney before you sign the purchase and sale, not after a default.
Questions people ask
Do most North Shore deals fall through?
I do not have a sourced local failure rate, so I will not print one. Deals fail here for the same contract reasons they fail elsewhere: inspection, financing, appraisal, title, and people who do not perform. The contract in front of you matters more than a national anecdote.
Is the earnest money always refundable in Massachusetts?
Only when the contract says it is, and only if you follow that clause on time. There is no automatic refund for changing your mind after the contingencies are gone.
How much is a typical deposit?
There is no typical amount I can cite from a statute. Read the offer and the purchase and sale. The number at risk is the number those documents name.
Can the seller keep the deposit and also sue?
The purchase and sale answers that. Some contracts treat the deposit as the seller’s remedy. Some preserve other claims. Ask the attorney who negotiated your document. Do not assume.
How fast can a seller relist?
As soon as the first contract is actually over and you know the status of the deposit. Relisting while a buyer still claims the right to close creates two deals. Clear the first one in writing, then come back to market with an honest explanation and a current price.